Saturday, February 2, 2008

Choosing a Candidate

They say you should never discuss politics or religion, but here I am broaching the subject. We talked about candidate-picking quizzes a bit at Fun Times, and I went home and found several options (and took them all). I wanted to pass along the URLs....perhaps they will be helpful at the polls on Tuesday. I'll keep the results in the comments section, so if you don't want to know how much of a commie bastard I am, don't read the comments.

First is my favorite from the last election, from SelectSmart. It gets right to the issues and allows you to provide a priority level for each question: SelectSmart

Next up is the Electoral Compass, which not only shows candidate affinities but also places you on an economic left/right and social progressive/conservative spectrum: Electoral Compass

Next, from a small-town news channel in Illinois, is WQAD's Select a Candidate Quiz. Simple, but still surprisingly accurate.

Next up is my least favorite, USAToday's Candidate Match Game. I didn't really like the questions, but it includes every candidate, including those that dropped out long ago. It's also pretty fun, graphically.

Glassbooth asks you to prioritize the issues, then tailors the questions to the importance you place on each topic.

The last is perhaps the most interesting, and definitely the most unique. It explores the mathematical concepts behind voting in general, and demonstrates that an election result could be changed by the manner in which it's conducted. It's part of Mathematics Awareness Month.

Happy voting!

4 comments:

  1. Here are my results from each of the tests:

    SelectSmart
    Obama - 83%
    Kucinich - 80%
    Biden - 80%
    Clinton - 80%
    Edwards - 76%
    Clark - 76%
    Gore - 74%
    That's one for Barack.

    Electoral Compass
    Obama - 78%
    Edwards - 75%
    Clinton - 74%
    Richardson - 73%
    That's two for Barack.

    WQAD
    Obama - 58
    Clinton - 58
    Gravel - 48
    This one's a tie, but it's still at least 2.5 for Barack.

    USAToday
    1 - Kucinich
    2 - Obama
    3 - Biden
    Kucinich? What the hell?

    GlassBooth
    Obama - 84%
    Clinton - 84%
    Gravel - 83%
    Another Barack.

    Math Month
    The Math Month outcomes aren't exactly like the others...more of a compilation than a personal suggestion.

    Conclusion
    In the end, the choice seems clear. Even if the results weren't so overwhelming, there are factors that no test can really take into account...a dislike for nepotism, a desire for change, and a chance to start over fresh both domestically and internationally.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Here are my results from each of the tests:

    SelectSmart
    Alan Keyes - 58%
    Barack Obama - 55%
    Joseph Biden - 55%
    Dennis Kucinich - 54%
    Ron Paul - 53%
    John Edwards - 52%
    Hillary Clinton - 51%
    John McCain - 49%
    Not an overwhelming preference indicated.

    Electoral Compass
    Ron Paul - 69%
    Barack Obama - 65%
    John Edwards - 63%
    Bill Richardson - 62%
    Hillary Clinton - 61%
    John McCain - 60%
    Mike Huckabee - 60%
    Mitt Romney - 58%
    Rudy Giuliani - 56%
    Fred Thompson - 53%
    That's more in-line with what I was thinking before the quiz… Except for Hillary and Rudy, I am not a fan of either. .

    WQAD
    Barack Obama - 24
    Hillary Clinton - 24
    Rudy Giuliani - 22
    Mitt Romney - 19
    Ron Paul - 19
    John McCain - 17
    Mike Gravel - 15
    Mike Huckabee - 14
    Again, Hillary showing up in my results. Maybe I should consider her… NOT!

    USAToday
    1 - Tom Tancredo
    2 - Mike Huckabee
    3 - Mitt Romney
    Tancredo? Huckabee? Romney? Well, I kind of like Romney… kind of.

    GlassBooth
    Mike Gravel - 69%
    Barack Obama - 66%
    Ron Paul - 65%
    Another Ron Paul/Barack result. They’re the Crockett and Tubbs of this election? Why is Tubbs dressed like the Jolly Green Giant? (who’s story is that from?).

    Conclusion
    In the end, the choice is not so clear. I love Ron Paul’s approach and agree with most of his strict Constitutionalist views. Unfortunately, I don’t think the mainstream is going to consider him a “real” (read media anointed candidate), and so Barack seems to be the right choice for my odd internal conflict of not wanting large government but recognizing that we currently have a large government, so wanting it to be run wisely. Anyway, the first quiz chose Hillary as the best choice for my wife, so I have bigger problems.

    ReplyDelete
  3. ps Every month is Math Month as far as I'm concerned.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm not sure about the accuracy of Electoral Compass - - it aligned me with Ron Paul.

    ReplyDelete